From: Census2000 <Census2000(a)ccmc.org>
Administration Spells Out Need for Extra Census Funds
As Senate Appropriators Meet to Consider Fiscal Year 2000 Request
President Clinton has sent to Congress specific proposals to revise his
original fiscal year 2000 (FY2000) budget request for the 2000 census
and several other federal programs. In a written statement, the
President said the Census Bureau needs $1.723 billion more than his
original request of $2.78 billion next year to count the population
without relying on statistical sampling. The President cited a January
Supreme Court ruling that federal law bars such methods for purposes of
congressional apportionment. The extra money brings the total FY2000
budget request for Census 2000 to $4.5 billion. The Senate
appropriations committee is scheduled to consider the funding bill
today.
The bulk of the extra $1.7 billion is needed for non-response follow-up,
when census enumerators visit households that don't mail back their
census forms. In order to comply with the Supreme Court decision,
enumerators must visit all 45 million households the Bureau estimates
will not mail back a questionnaire. The increased field workload will
cost an extra $1.45 billion. This amount includes money to hire more
temporary workers and extend their training; a recheck of an estimated
7.6 million housing units reported as vacant, as well interviews to
gather information missing from returned questionnaires; enhanced
procedures for counting people who have no usual residence at soup
kitchens and shelters; and a pre-census quality check of rural areas
without city-style addresses.
The additional funds also will cover more supplies, materials,
telephones, and other infrastructure needs to support a larger workforce
(+$234 million); keeping the four data processing centers open longer to
accommodate the expanded field operation (+$102 million); additional
advertising and promotion, including more materials for schools,
nonprofit groups, and local governments (+$88 million); and several
other new efforts to improve address lists and data collection. The
Bureau says it will save $214 million by reducing the size of the
post-census quality check survey (called the Accuracy and Coverage
Evaluation program) from 750,000 households under its original plan to
300,000 households.
Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-NY), co-chair of the Congressional Census Caucus
and the senior Democrat on the House census oversight panel, said the
President's revised Census 2000 budget request represented a "true
lose-lose proposition." Taxpayers must pay more, she said, "for a less
accurate count."
Coincidentally, the President also asked for additional FY2000 funds for
several other programs covered under the same budget account that covers
the Census Bureau. The $2.5 billion worth of changes in the
Administration's total FY2000 budget request includes an extra $264
million for improved security at U.S. embassies overseas and $230 for
the Immigration and Naturalization Service's detention and deportation
program. The State Department and the Justice Department (which houses
the INS) must compete for funds against other activities covered under
the Commerce, Justice, and State, The Judiciary, and Related Agencies
appropriations bill. The Census Bureau is an agency of the Commerce
Department. The President proposed to pay for the $2.5 billion he
requested by accelerating a 1997 tax change affecting individuals with
annual incomes over $150,000 and by slowing federal payments to the
states for "welfare to work" programs.
Census Monitoring Board news: The Presidential appointees of the Census
Monitoring Board sent an interim report to Congress yesterday "that
documents significant bipartisan support throughout the country for the
Census Bureau's plan" to correct undercounts and overcounts using
statistical sampling methods, according to a press release announcing
the report. The three members who issued the document (there is one
vacancy on the panel's Presidential side) compiled letters from state
and local officials in support of the Bureau's plan to conduct a
300,000-household post-enumeration survey to account for people missed
in the direct count. The report will be available on the Presidential
members' Web site
www.cmbp.gov <http://www.cmbp.gov> in the near future.
Meanwhile, Kenneth Blackwell, the Board's Republican co-chair, said he
would not step down from the Board despite his appointment as chairman
of Steve Forbes's campaign for the presidency. In a June 3 letter,
House Census Subcommittee Chairman Dan Miller (R-FL) asked Mr. Blackwell
to resign, saying he was concerned about "the appearance of
incompatibility of the two roles." Calling Mr. Blackwell "a rising
star in our party," Rep. Miller accused Democrats of "politiciz[ing] the
census at every opportunity." He distinguished Mr. Blackwell's new
campaign position from the appointment of the Board's former Democratic
co-chair, Tony Coelho, as general chairman of Vice President Albert
Gore's presidential campaign, since Mr. Coelho would be "running the
[Gore campaign's] day-to-day operations." Mr. Coelho resigned from the
Board last month. Rep. Miller said that his call for Mr. Blackwell's
resignation "has more to do with politics than reality" because
"Democrats will use [Mr. Blackwell's campaign position] as a political
weapon to distract the public from the real problems with the 2000
census."
In his reply of June 3, Mr. Blackwell said he "left politics at the
door" in carrying out his Monitoring Board duties, and noted that the
Board had issued a joint report to Congress last April. "[I]t would be
counter-productive for me to abandon the process," Mr. Blackwell wrote.
"I am uniquely positioned to address the principal problem that exists
in the 2000 Census - counting real people where they actually live."
Not satisfied with Mr. Blackwell's decision to remain on the Board, Rep.
Carolyn Maloney wrote to House Speaker J. Dennis Hastert (R-IL) and
Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott (R-MS) this week, urging them to seek
the co-chairman's resignation. Senator Lott appointed two of the
Monitoring Board's eight members; Rep. Hastert's predecessor, former
Speaker Newt Gingrich (R-GA), also named two members. The President
appointed four members and must now fill the vacancy left by Mr.
Coelho's resignation.
Upcoming news: The House Subcommittee on the Census held a hearing
yesterday to review several proposals affecting the way prisoners,
members of the armed forces, and Americans living overseas are counted
in the census. Rep. Benjamin Gilman (R-NY) advocated a "sense of the
Congress" resolution in support of counting all Americans living
overseas. The Census Bureau plans to count members of the armed forces,
federal civilian employees, and their dependents stationed overseas at
their "home of record," as it did in 1990, for purposes of congressional
apportionment only. Subcommittee member Rep. Paul Ryan (R-WI) urged the
Bureau to count military personnel stationed in the U.S. at their "home
of record" (the place where the service member enlisted), as well, at
least for apportionment purposes. The Bureau counts military personnel
at the place where they usually live and sleep at the time of the census
(called "usual place of residence"), a long-standing policy that
determines where all persons are counted.
Rep. Mark Green (R-WI) urged the subcommittee to consider his bill (H.R.
1632) to require that inmates serving their time in an out-of-state
facility be counted as residents of the state that pays more than half
the cost of their incarceration. The Census 2000 Initiative will
provide a more complete summary of the proceedings next week. The
Initiative also will report on a Justice Department memorandum
concerning the effect of a provision in the 1996 immigration reform law
on the confidentiality of citizenship or immigration data collected in
the census. Prepared at the request of the Commerce Department's
general counsel, the analysis concludes that a provision of the Illegal
Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 does not
override section 9(a) of the Census Act (title 13, United States Code),
which protects individual census responses from all other government
agencies, the courts, and private individuals.
Questions about the information contained in this News Alert may be
directed to TerriAnn Lowenthal at 202/484-2270 or, by e-mail at
<terriann2k(a)aol.com>om>. For copies of previous News Alerts and other
information, use our web site
www.census2000.org
<http://www.census2000.org>. Please direct all requests to receive
News Alerts, and all changes in address/phone/fax/e-mail, to the Census
2000 Initiative at <Census2000(a)ccmc.org> or 202/326-8700. Please feel
free to circulate this information to colleagues and other interested
individuals.