from: Census 2000 Initiative
date: October 13, 1998
Congress and White House Still Struggling to Reach Accord On
Census Funding as Clock Ticks Toward Adjournment
With most government agencies operating under a stopgap
spending bill that runs out at midnight tomorrow, Congress
and the Administration are still trying to reach agreement
on funding for 2000 census preparations in the current
fiscal year that began October 1. Reports earlier today
that an agreement had been reached could not be confirmed.
Critics of the Census Bureau's plan to supplement the
traditional headcount with sampling methods reportedly want
to provide funding for 2000 census activities only through
February, forcing Congress and the Administration to make a
final decision by then on whether sampling can be used. The
truncated funding would apply to the departments of
Commerce, Justice, State and the Judiciary, the budget
account which includes the Census Bureau. Congressional
supporters of the Bureau's plan continue to call for a full
year of funding. The Supreme Court will hear arguments in
two lawsuits challenging the use of sampling on November 30;
a decision could be rendered by early next year. [See below
for update on the lawsuits.] The entire Commerce
appropriations bill is likely to be included in a larger
spending package covering numerous agencies and programs for
which separate funding measures have not been signed into
law.
Census director nomination awaits final action: Dr. Kenneth
Prewitt, President Clinton's choice to head the Census
Bureau, awaits confirmation by the Senate after the
Committee on Governmental Affairs approved his nomination by
voice vote on September 24. Committee aides say the full
Senate could vote on the Prewitt appointment in the coming
days before Congress adjourns but that the decision is in
the hands of the Senate leadership.
Lawsuit update: Several organizations concerned about the
outcome of the 2000 census filed friend-of-the-court briefs
in the case of U.S. House of Representatives v. U.S.
Department of Commerce. On November 30, the Supreme Court
will hear the government's appeal of the district court
ruling that the Census Act bars the use of sampling for
purposes of congressional apportionment.
The Supreme Court announced that it will hear the
government's appeal in the second census lawsuit, Glavin v.
Clinton, at the same time. Like the court in the U.S. House
of Representatives case, a federal district court in
Virginia ruled last month that sampling was unlawful but did
not consider whether the Constitution also barred those
methods. By combining the two cases, the Court may have a
greater opportunity to decide whether the Census Act and the
Constitution permit sampling for apportionment because the
parties bringing the lawsuits have different stakes in the
outcome. For example, if the Court finds that Congress does
not have legal standing to challenge the Census Bureau's
plan, it could still consider the substantive issues if the
individual and local government plaintiffs in the Glavin
case meet the constitutional standards for challenging the
sampling methods.
Among the parties filing "amicus briefs" in support of the
Commerce Department's appeal were the State of Texas, the
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal
Employees (AFSCME), Japanese American Citizens League, ACLU,
Puerto Rican Legal Defense and Education Fund, National
Urban League, American Jewish Committee, American Jewish
Congress, and the Brennan Center for Justice/New York
University School of Law. Briefs in support of the
plaintiff's challenge to sampling are due by November 3.
The Supreme Court convenes to hear cases at 10:00 a.m.
Individuals interested in observing oral arguments in the
census case should call the Court's Public Information
Office at 202/479-3000. A limited number of reserved seats
are available; the line for same-day public seats forms
daily on the front steps of the Court building.
Congressional subcommittee plans field hearings: The House
Subcommittee on the Census announced plans for a series of
field hearings to review local efforts to promote census
participation. In a letter to stakeholder organizations,
Chairman Dan Miller (R-FL) said his panel will visit areas
that had the largest undercounts in 1990 to review "at the
local level innovative ways to find and count all Americans"
in 2000. He asked stakeholders to share their ideas and
suggest possible witnesses for the hearings, and called upon
stakeholders "to get serious about planing for an actual
count" in light of congressional opposition to sampling and
recent court rulings that the Census Act prohibits those
methods. The subcommittee has not announced sites for the
hearings.
Executive Branch news: The Census Bureau's professional,
race and ethnic, and 2000 census advisory committees will
meet jointly on October 26 to discuss the paid advertising
campaign for the 2000 census. Representatives of Young &
Rubicam, the ad agency developing the campaign under
contract with the Bureau, will participate in the
discussions. The meeting will be held at the Sheraton
Reston Hotel, 11810 Sunrise Valley Drive, Reston, VA (tel:
703/620-9000), from 8:00 a.m. - 5:45 p.m., and is open to
the public.
Stakeholder activities: The 2000 Census Advisory Committee
is drafting a final report that it will present to the
Secretary of Commerce in February, one month before the
committee's charter expires. The report will summarize the
panel's work over the past two years and make
recommendations on a wide range of operational and technical
issues affecting the 2000 census. Census Bureau staff
presented information on the status of dress rehearsal
operations but cautioned that analysis of the results was
not complete. Census workers had finished non-response
follow-up visits in all three dry-run sites, as well as,
return visits for the quality-check sample survey in
Sacramento and the Menominee Indian reservation. The Bureau
plans to issue a "report card" on the dress rehearsal by the
end of January; evaluations will be finished in March 1999.
Deputy Secretary of Commerce Robert Mallett reported that
Commerce Department officials were visiting all of the
Bureau's regional offices to assess fiscal and personnel
resource needs for the temporary regional census centers and
more than 500 local census offices that will open in 1999.
The advisory committee's next meeting is December 3 - 4.
Questions about the information contained in this News Alert
may be directed to TerriAnn Lowenthal at (202) 484-2270 or,
by e-mail at <terriann2k(a)aol.com>om>. Please direct all
requests to receive News Alerts, and all changes in
address/phone/fax/e-mail, to Census 2000 at
<census2000(a)ccmc.org> or 202/326-8700. Please feel free to
circulate this information to colleagues and other
interested individuals